It is important to remember that every case is different -- in terms of what helps, what harms, and how long treatment takes. Similar symptoms can have different underlying causes. Treatment for fresh cases and more entrenched cases can be very different. (Prevention of a problem, vs. treatment of it once it crops up, may be different too.)
I don't think I've ever seen as wide a variety of different medical opinions online, even on reputable websites, as I have for foot and ankle problems. Some of the advice I'm getting is exactly the opposite of Maki's. It's complicated.
One of the few things the different schools of thought seem to agree on is that these conditions are much easier to treat if you catch them in their early stages. The one piece of general advice I'd feel comfortable giving is, if you think you're starting to have a problem, see a doc sooner rather than later if you possibly can.