Voltage controls the amount of amps which can flow.
All vehicle platforms are different as to what voltages are allowed and when and for how long.
AGMs tend to like higher amperage charge rates, but some of the lesser$$ AGMS have a 30% limit. 30 amps per 100AH of capacity, and on these batteries, letting loose a well wired alternator on a battery depleted below 80% can greatly exceed this rate, which can cause the vents to open, and irretrievable loss of electrolyte, and premature battery death.
Higher$$ AGMS like Odyssey, Northstar and Lifeline do not have any restrictions placed on maximum amperage, and actually do better when charged at super high rate. Odyssey say no less than 40 amps per 100AH of capacity on a deeply cycled battery, Lifeline says no less than 20 amps. Northstar is more Wishywashy on their minimum charge rates, but in my experience with mine, the higher the better.
Odyssey also says that 40 amps must be applied until 14.7v is reached, then it is to be held for 4 hours. On an Odyssey battery, 14.2v held for an Hour is a recipe for unimpressive battery longevity, from a very expensive battery. On other forums there are lots of complaints about unimpressive battery longevity on Odysseys which are deep cycled and only alternator recharged over much too thin of cabling, for too short a drive. They blame the battery, when it is the improper recharging of it which is to blame for an unimpressive lifespan
I so Wish that an affordable plug in charger allowed the control that my Solar controller allows. Adjustable absorption voltage combined with adjustable duration at which absorption voltage is held is key to fully charging a battery and key to ultimate lifespan.
The more shallow the discharge, the less important it is that the high amp requirements are met. My 200 watts of solar is usually enough to replace the AH I use nightly, but it cannot do it at the rate which keeps my Northstar AGM happiest, not with discharges to 50% nightly. Not even close.
So my Strategy with my single and only battery, a Northstar group 27AGM is a well wired alternator, a 40 amp meanwell adjustable voltage power supply as a plug in charger, and 198 watts of Solar. All three. No way could solar alone keep this battery happy, not with ~50% discharges nightly.
I have a battery monitor right next to my throne and watch the voltage held under certain loads and AH removed and get a great Idea as to how my battery is performing, and after 4 cycles of a low and slow solar only recharge, even to a "100%" state daily, has voltage sagging under this load on night 4 compared to night one. One single high amp recharge restores this loss of performance.
The High Amp requirement of AGMS cannot be understated. Some AGMS are limited as to their maximum amps allowed during charging, but they still benefit from amperages upto these maximums and the deeper their discharge the more they benefit from it. If the discharges are shallow the high amp recharge necessity lessens greatly.
The 30% limited AGMS might very well be more tolerant of Low and slow solar only recharges compared to the higher $$ AGMS which have no upper limits on charging amps.
AGMS tend to get painted with the same brush but their requirements among various brands are Widely variable, and the wise AGM owner knows who actually makes their battery, and what the manufacturer recommended absorption voltage is, as well as how long to hold it and minimum and maximum recommended charging rates.
Ultimately it is the number and depth of cycles which defines how well a battery handles any given charging/discharging scenario.
'Just fine, so far' means nothing, compared to "just fine" for 400 cycles now to 50% depth of discharge.
With an unknown depth of discharge, unknown amount of cycles, and unknown amount of performance loss,......
Batteries lose capacity as they age. How quickly they lose it is determined by how well they are recharged. If a person does not have the tools or desire or Knowledge on how to judge performance/capacity loss, everything is 'just fine', until that one day it is not.
Whether the battery gave good enough service to the owner is subjective.
If the battery fails at an inconvenient time, with no warning to the 'just finers', then it can be more than inconvenient and expensive to replace it.
67888, Our Dodges have wacked out voltage regulation. Mine will seesaw between 13.7v and 14.9v, completely devoid of any Logic. Sometimes when the battery is depleted all it allows is 13.7v and few recharging amps flow, other times when I know the battery is as charged as it can get, the Dodge's VR allows 14.9v into a battery which does not need it. Northstar says at 77F, absorption voltage is to be 14.46v, so 14.9v is well outside this parameter, and significantly more alternator amps can flow at 14.9 vs 14.4v. Perhaps too much, though i have not noticed any significant degradation in performance from allowing it.
I have a solution for this, but I have not yet employed it. It requires tricking and bypassing the VR inside the engine computer, and employing an external one. Doing so without illuminatng the check engine light is the hard part. My goal is to have a potentiometer on My dashboard which allows me to control the voltage when driving from the driver's seat, as this wishy washy 13.7/ 14.9v habit is a bit infuriating to someone as anal retentive as myself. I will start a thread on this once I have employed it and made it functional.
I miss those ignorance was bliss days, but I don't miss replacing improperly recharged batteries every 6 to 12 months, and always worrying that the end might be near.