akrvbob said:
...I think there is another, very dark side of the story.
You said it well. That is such an important aspect of credit that I dropped the ball by not highlighting that in the OP. Any other threads I start related to credit will include the seductiveness of easy credit and the potential life-altering downfall of misusing credit. Being in debt is like being in jail without bars. You aren't living free if you are tied down by massive debt. Then, yes, the sheeple among us must cow to the overlords. In that sense, debt can be one of the biggest forms of evil I can think of.
I don't think of having credit as a scam. Anything can be scammed and manipulated with credit being an easy one to use against you (or you unwittingly using it against yourself), but it is not inherently bad. It is a tool that one has a surprising amount of control over. I find it a valuable and use it to my advantage. Do I need it? No. I don't need electricity either, but it sure is nice.
When I eventually have a battery bank and solar, if I "spend" more electricity than I can have or can make, I don't get the luxury of putting some juice on my Electricity VISA. Neither am I the Federal Government; I must operate within my electrical limits or pay the price. No entitlement there.
Managing credit well does show a lot about your character. I'm not saying if you have bad credit, you are a bad person, but it does statistically demonstrate that those with good credit are safer drivers, more reliable when renting, etc. Of course there are exceptions. While most companies will consider your credit in context (eg. severe medical debt), not all do, which is an abuse of FICO.
Some credit cards have points or hearts or whatever it is that isn't cash. Those have much higher reward values, but what you can spend them on, when you can spend them on, and if they expire are cards that are B.S. I don't want to play those games. All I want to do is be rewarded for paying my bills on time in an easy to understand way that doesn't require me to frequently log in and be on time to be able to take advantage my "points".
When applying for something, we want to show who we truly are. Much of the time all we have is our word, which means squat to most people because too many people lie. And a whole other group of people have deluded themselves into thinking they are good, but aren't, which is another reason why many people won't take you at your word. FICO is one way of objectively and tactfully showing who we are as a person to some credible degree. Even an egg has a heart of gold, but you don't know until you break it open. FICO allows that heart of gold to shine.