SternWake, I had been following that thread but then hadn't checked it for a few days. When next I logged in here, I found this thread and wondered what the drama was about. By that time, your post had been deleted, but I saw part of it in someone's quote of you. You wrote: "We need Data, not supposition, not justification, not opinion. No data, then, in my opinion, then kindly stfu." I still wondered what the drama was about after seeing that.
To me, your comment was obviously NOT an ad hominem attack as it wasn't addressed to anyone specific. You stated clearly that it was your opinion and it seemed to me that saying "kindly stfu" the way you did was in the same vein as phrases like "**** or get off the pot" and "show me the money." I can't even fathom how it was misconstrued as a direct attack on anybody. Is it just because I'm a New Yorker that I got it?
It can be easy to misinterpret the written word because it is not accompanied by tone, body language, and vocal inflection, but in this instance, the misinterpretation seems way off to me. I moderate another forum where we do not allow ad hominem attacks and I wouldn't have issued a demerit for what you posted. If someone was a known troublemaker, it might have garnered a warning. I think you're owed an apology, IMHO.
Sorry you feel your time here was wasted, and sorry to see you go.