Battery advice needed

Van Living Forum

Help Support Van Living Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

IanC

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 8, 2016
Messages
617
Reaction score
1
Location
Western Massachusetts
I just saw 4 Trojan golf cart batteries on Craigslist for 100 bucks each. I spoke to the guy and he said he had purchased the wrong ones and these have been sitting uncharged - barely used. From the pictures they don't look that new. The manufacture date on them is 2/15.  Is this something I'm going to regret, or do you think I should take a chance even given a possible diminished lifespan?

http://westernmass.craigslist.org/snw/5874860737.html
 
IanC said:
I just saw 4 Trojan golf cart batteries on Craigslist for 100 bucks each. I spoke to the guy and he said he had purchased the wrong ones and these have been sitting uncharged - barely used. From the pictures they don't look that new. The manufacture date on them is 2/15.  Is this something I'm going to regret, or do you think I should take a chance even given a possible diminished lifespan?

http://westernmass.craigslist.org/snw/5874860737.html

One has 1-15 and three have 2-15.  One seems to be a different height.  

They list for about $200 each.  

They are taller than a regular battery. 

2 years old.  

It is recommended that you buy a set of cheap batteries as your first ones.  That way you can learn without it costing a lot.  

If they will hold a charge, they might be a good buy.
 
GotSmart said:
One has 1-15 and three have 2-15.  One seems to be a different height.  

They list for about $200 each.  

They are taller than a regular battery. 

2 years old.  

It is recommended that you buy a set of cheap batteries as your first ones.  That way you can learn without it costing a lot.  

If they will hold a charge, they might be a good buy.
 
Those trojans are about as a robust lead acid battery as one could buy.

But they are not immune form self discharge, and sitting undercharged will cause the sulfation to harden. and be extremely difficult to be driven back into the electrolyte.

Perhaps recharged properly, and then equalized their capacity could be returned to 80% or more of their original capacity, but if they were discharged when taken from service and never recharged, then they are likely only worth their weight in lead( pb)

If i were in the market and presented this opportuinty I would bring my hydrometer and voltmeter and a strong LED flashlight to shine down into the cells. I would bring my 40 amp charger and hook 2 of them in series and see how quickly voltage rose when 40 amps was applied and how quickly Specific gravity rose.

All these data points would give Clues to remaining capacity and potential recoverable capacity, but it would eb a guess and a proper recharge and extended equalization and then a 20 hour capacity test would heva to be performed to definitively say whether they were worth 100$ each.

it could go either way and without any sort of clue, one is entirely guessing that it will or will not be 200 dollars well spent.

200$ as you need two of them for 12V
 
IMO I would check around for the price on new non-Trojan batteries also.  I got Eveready GC2s at Sam's Club 2 years ago for (if I remember right) $83.00 each;  Manufactured date 1 month before purchase.  You can then decide if the better quality of Trojan makes the risk worth it for you.

 -- Spiff
 
If you can find new Duracell labeled batteries at Batteries plus Bulbs, or a eastern Sam's Club, you will have a much better battery at about $209 each than those dead dogs.
 
I decided not to take the chance and bought a couple of Interstate golf carts instead. I would have preferred Trojan, but the closest dealer is an hour's drive from me. The Interstates were $160 each but I'm glad I spent the extra rather than take the chance on the old Trojans.
 
IanC said:
I decided not to take the chance and bought a couple of Interstate golf carts instead. I would have preferred Trojan, but the closest dealer is an hour's drive from me. The Interstates were $160 each but I'm glad I spent the extra rather than take the chance on the old Trojans.

You have to live with your choices.  You chose to not take chances.  Interstates have a good warranty.  Sometimes it is hard to find a dealer, but there are quite a few out there.  Happy powering!
 
dang where do you live? around here I can get Trojan T-105's for 120 bucks. brand new and fresh. highdesertranger
 
The Interstate grp 27 sitting on the tongue of my trailer right now is in its sixth season and still doing it's job even with testing the fridge, A/C, solar, etc. It runs the trailer while the big bank runs the toys. I am sure there are better brands but how much more could I expect were I to spend the money?
 
Top