Please recommend a Good Propane Detector.

Van Living Forum

Help Support Van Living Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

One Awesome Inch

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 14, 2013
Messages
1,170
Reaction score
0
I found a good carbon monoxide detector on Amazon for about $20.

Does anyone have a recommendation for a propane gas detector that they are happy with? 
 
Perhaps what is in quotes below is why I cannot find a battery powered (not battery backup) propane detector? Thoughts?

Propane detectors work by using a heated wire and a smoke detector.  If there is propane or another flammable gas present then the heated wire will generate smoke.

The most efficient propane detectors draw around 1 watt of electrical power to heat the wire.  That's around 80 mA at 12 volts which works out to 2 AH per day, not an insignificant amount.  With D batteries you'd use up a battery every day.
 
As propane has the 'smelly' chemical added and is quite noticeable, I wonder if it's simply not really necessary to spend money and amps on a detector? The nose knows......
 
I've been trying to decide what to do about this also, as I haven't installed solar yet and only have one house battery. The only problem with relying on the old nose is, well, I have an old nose. I've smelled so many fumes over the years that it has to get to a fairly high concentration before I smell it. Also, unlike natural gas, propane is heavier than air so it settles. It is quite possible to get a concentration that is ignitable before you smell it, especially if you have say, a Mr Buddy Heater sitting on the floor with an open flame pilot. Remember, that oxygen sensor built into it isn't really an oxygen sensor, it's actually just a thermal couple. When there is less oxygen to burn the flame gets smaller until the thermal couple cools and the gas is shut off. Up to the point of the gas shutting off, there is still a flame, and it is sitting about 3'' off the floor. If your head is say, 18'' to 24'' off the floor on your pillow, at the opposite end of your rig, will you for sure smell the gas before it reaches the pilot? That's probably reason enough to only run your appliances when you're awake and present.
 
One Awesome Inch said:
I found a good carbon monoxide detector on Amazon for about $20.

Does anyone have a recommendation for a propane gas detector that they are happy with? 

Kidde KN-COEG-3 Carbon Monoxide Alarm / Explosive Gas Alarm (good for 7 years) it came packaged with a smoke detector (good for 10 years).

ALL SMOKE DETECTORS, CO DETECTORS & GAS DETECTORS HAVE A LIMITED LIFE AFTER WHICH THEY SHOULD BE REPLACED. I suggest that you write the expiration date on the face/side of the detector so you will know when you are approaching the expiration date so you can get a new one.
 
Hey Compassrose, thanks for the link. I noticed it's battery backup, but made to be plugged into a 110 volt outlet. Do you have any idea how long it will run on just the 9 volt battery? I only turn on my inverter when I need it, as it draws power itself with the fan etc... I'm wondering if I can run it for a week or two on batteries, even if I have to replace them a couple times, and run it on 110 when I have shore power available.
 
I have one very similar to this one at Amazon:

 http://www.amazon.com/Motorhome-Trailer-Monoxide-Propane-Detector/dp/B003ZJLD3G 

[font=Arial, sans-serif]RV Motorhome and Trailer 12V CO Carbon Monoxide & Propane Detector Alarm[/font]


This ties into your existing 12VDC system and draws very little power.  Being a propane detector in addition to a C0 detector, it should be mounted near the floor as propane is heavier than air.
 
Top