Credit Card v. Charge Card v. Debit Card v. PayPal

Van Living Forum

Help Support Van Living Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Canine

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
2,688
Reaction score
2
Location
Great Falls, MT
Firstly, knowing that credit can be misused and the resulting consequences is important to know. I don't have a problem with it, but lots of people do. I have a checking account and have at times, when I was young, made mistakes with it. I'm also not perfect with my credit card, but pretty close. Definitely not so bad that I'm paying late fees, over the limit fees, or interest. I will occasionally pay a small amount of interest for a couple weeks or so. I have a friend that can't even keep a checking account because she is so bad with money. Honestly, I don't understand how one can get into some much trouble, excluding extenuating circumstances, that financial ruin quickly ensues. But being aware of it is important. The following is information on different options, relative to each other, on how one can manage and use their money/credit.

Credit cards are revolving credit. You don't need to ask for a loan each time you need money, you just get the money immediately in your hot little hands. Some offer rewards that you get back when using their card. Those rewards are lost from interest if you don't pay the bill in full at the end of the month, and interest rates on those cards are high. If you want a basic card, those have the cheaper rates (not always) and the FICO score required isn't as high. Then it goes up from there. You can have annual fees or not. You can get NHL, NFL, NBA, etc. cars. Sam's and Costco offer rewards cards that wave the annual fee with relatively high rewards. There are gas cards, miles cards, flyer cards, and just about anything you can think of. You can get one as complicated as you want or a simple one. Some cards offer car rental insurance, travel insurance, increased warranties, and more. Since many of us travel, a card that offers a high return on fuel is appealing. Those of us that have large families may prefer high rewards on groceries. Sometimes you can get special offers that aren't yet available to the public like concert tickets. Better acceptance when out of the country.

You can also get a secured card. You put up collateral in the form of a CD or something like that and you can get a credit card. It has all the perks and works the same as a non-secured card.

Charge cards work the same as credit cards except you must pay the balance in full at the end of every month.

Debit cards DO NOT work the same way as credit cards, nor do you get the perks that automatically come with credit cards. A debit card is a lot like having a checking account. Debit cards have more risk than credit cards. They are similar in that they are sponsored by VISA or Mastercard. You can swipe them to buy stuff or you can enter the number online for purchases. Should a card become compromised, a credit card has to foot the bill except for the first $50, but most of the time they will not make you pay for any fraudulent purchase. I've had it happen to me three times so far and have paid $0. With a debit card, you are on the hook for all of it. If the crook drains your account, it's on you; however, banks will often put that money back into your account at their expense, but they aren't required to. Debit card usage does not increase your FICO score. You don't need good credit to acquire a debit card. Costco quit accepting credit cards, but love those debit cards. You can still use a credit card online for Costco. If your bank account is hacked and you have outstanding checks or automatic withdrawals, at about $30 for each over-the-limit fee, you could have a costly situation. A much more costly situation than if it had occurred with a credit card. The legal protection offered to debit cards is much, much lower.

When using a debit or credit card at a gas station, be aware that your card will have a "hold" put on it to make sure you have enough cash/credit available to make the purchase. This can be up to $75 and up to $150 at truck stops. Then the hold can be on your card for up to 3 days. Often it is just a few hours. I'll tell you what happened to me. My dog started having seizures, so I made an emergency trip to the vet, which was expensive. A couple days before that, I had made a large purchase, so my card was getting "full". I still had about $300 left and had a break down and needed to charge a part. (When it rains, it pours!) The part was something like $250, so I easily had enough credit, but the charge was denied. This surprised me, but I make mistakes, so I went to the bank to fix the error I had likely made. Turns out I didn't make an error. When the vet charged me on a Saturday, the card wasn't actually charge, but a hold had been put on it. Then on Monday, the card was actually charged. The amount was about $750, but I still had a hold of $750 for a total of $1500 which easily put me over my available credit. Holds don't come off immediately after a charge- they come off sometimes several hours later. This is what happened to me. I happened to try to use my credit card during that period where the card was charged yet still had a hold on it. The same can happen with a debit card.

Also, the bank rep explained to me sometimes an employee like a clerk at a motel will swipe your card to see if it has enough money on it to rent a room. Let's say the room is $100 with tax. When the clerk checks the card, a hold is put on it. Then when the card shows there is enough money, that clerk will swipe it again and charge the card, but that puts another hold on it. So two holds plus one charge is $300. This is not a common occurrence, but it can happen. Good information to know for both credit cards and debit cards.

PayPal sucks. I had it and made many hundreds of dollars on Ebay. I enjoyed the heck out of it for the most part, but when I learned of the bad things that can happen, I stopped using my Ebay account. That was a sad day for me. Most of the negative applies to sellers, but can also affect buyers. PayPal is attached to an account. PayPal isn't governed by banking regulations because it isn't a bank, so they have tremendous amounts of leeway and far less legal accountability when it comes to doing whatever the hell it is that they want to do with YOUR money. They can freeze your account almost on a whim. You can be left without use of your funds for months while they have your money. Do they use that money for themselves to gain interest on investments? Maybe, but who knows. As far as I know you aren't allowed to know what they do with YOUR money while your account is frozen. To get away from PayPal you can use a merchant account, but that costs money. You can also use a separate bank account and if that is frozen, you still have access to the funds in the other account. I've had conversations about this with other people and they say they love PayPal and wouldn't change it. I really liked PayPal, too, but the risk of losing my business so easily and having my credit wrecked from potential arbitrary and overly punitive actions of PayPal was too much for me. If you want to learn more, go to www.paypalsucks.com.

I'm not an authority. We each have our own comfort levels in regards to risk management. Some people swear by cash and refuse any kind of credit, and that is fine. Nothing wrong with that at all. If that is your choice, I totally respect that and may even encourage it. For those of us that want to use some type of payment method other than cash, hopefully this information will be a springboard to help educate you to use your moneys in the most efficient, safest way possible. Each method has its own pros and cons and not one method is the best method for every transaction you may encounter. Bartering is uncommon, so we need to accept the way money is handled and that is a fluid situation. We should periodically check in on how we spend our money and adapt to make the best decisions.
 
Nice write up.

Personally, I would NEVER treat my debit card like a credit card - ie:  use it to buy stuff online or give it to a waiter in a restaurant.  It's only purpose is to get cash at ATMs or banks.

As far as PayPal goes, I've never sold on Ebay, only bought (and less and less of that, lately) but I have it linked to one of my credit cards and I find it convenient for online purchases when someplace will accept it.  Sort of doubles my recourse if there is a problem, if PayPal can't straighten the seller out, I can always dispute the charge with the credit card issuer.  PayPal keeps sending me emails telling me I need to "finish" setting up my account by linking it to my bank accounts, too.  Yeah, that will happen when Hell freezes over.

Regards
John
 
Optonoid, I haven't done Ebay in years. I should check into it again and see what's up. I know that they push PayPal because Ebay owns PayPal, but they do have other options that I'm sure I'm not aware of.
 
I have had two occurences of attempted credit card theft on PayPal, one they actually got the money - I had the CC company close that account and got the money back.  The second attempt was after that card was closed.  BOTH were initiated thru PayPal.  I avoid them like the plague.
Had a small CC through a bank, that I loaded money into in order to use it later.  Had them allow a foreign interest to steal my money, then they demanded I pay ALL money (twice what my limit was!) off in order to cancel the account.  Bad juju.  AVOID FIRST PREMIER BANK!!  THEY ARE THIEVES and CROOKS!!

I use a Master Card through Capital One - they treat me well, for a CC company.  I keep the credit limit to what I can pay off in one or two months.  Twice they tried to 'reward me by upping my credit limit.  I had them return it to what I set.
 I have a checking account, that my pension is paid into.  I then pay the CC via that.  I get an account print out from the bank each month, after the pension is paid.  I use this to double check my check book.

I have no use for charge cards or debit cards.
 
LeeRevell, that is a horror story about First Premier. Geez. One technique that may help to avoid the bank saying that you are the bad guy is to be aware of your card usage and report it as soon as possible. The sooner the better. Also, many cards have the ability to notify you by text or email if the card has a charge or charges greater than whatever amount you specify. I have mine set to notify me by email if the charge is over $500. You can also set your card to be denied if an individual charge is greater than whatever amount you specify. Mine was previously at $300, but I took it off. You have to let the bank know ahead of time if you want to make a larger charge, but that won't work if you need emergency funds on a weekend or holiday. You can also set the card to work only in the U.S. and not in any other country. You may be able to set it, for example, to work in the U.S. and Canada, but no other countries, but I don't know.

Keeping your limit low may hurt your credit score. Having it higher will help your score. But that is a choice you make based on your risk management for your individual needs and wants.

I keep a debit card to get cash without paying ATM fees when I use an ATM affiliated with my bank. An example might be if you find a good deal at a garage sale on the weekend, but don't have $300 cash on hand. You can ask them to hold it for 10 minutes while you go to the ATM for the cash. Most people won't balk at waiting a few minutes to get some cold, hard cash. If you use an ATM a lot, a debit card is the way to go to avoid ATM fees. I used to have direct deposit and would use the ATM every two weeks. My current job still sends a check, so I just go inside the bank, ask for some cash and deposit the rest of the check. I rarely use the ATM, so I could probably get away with not having a debit card.
 
Canine said:
Optonoid, I haven't done Ebay in years. I should check into it again and see what's up. I know that they push PayPal because Ebay owns PayPal, but they do have other options that I'm sure I'm not aware of.

I believe Ebay and PayPal have been split, or are being split, or something.

I'm finding more and more online places that offer PayPal as an option along with Visa, MasterCard, etc.  I prefer to use PayPal under those circumstances cause then that's one less place that gets told my number, exp date and 3 digit code.

Regards
John
 
Canine said:
LeeRevell, that is a horror story about First Premier. Geez. One technique that may help to avoid the bank saying that you are the bad guy is to be aware of your card usage and report it as soon as possible. The sooner the better. Also, many cards have the ability to notify you by text or email if the card has a charge or charges greater than whatever amount you specify. I have mine set to notify me by email if the charge is over $500. You can also set your card to be denied if an individual charge is greater than whatever amount you specify. Mine was previously at $300, but I took it off. You have to let the bank know ahead of time if you want to make a larger charge, but that won't work if you need emergency funds on a weekend or holiday. You can also set the card to work only in the U.S. and not in any other country. You may be able to set it, for example, to work in the U.S. and Canada, but no other countries, but I don't know.

None of that worked.  I had a low limit set ($350), First Premier Bank allowed the foreign entity (I tracked them online to France) to draw twice that amount.  I did not have the ability to keep an online look at my account then - I do now 'religiously'.  I check my CC account daily.  FP blatantly allowed this account theft, and I suspect was directly involved.  This was an account that was supposed to work as a "customer pays in before using it" deal.  It was MY money, not theirs at risk.  AVOID these types of CC cards.  It's a scam.  I was forced to pay MY money back in to the full amount stolen, in order to get quit of them.  Couldn't afford legal action at that time, or I'd have sued them.  I repeat - FIRST PREMIER BANK are thieves, pure and simple.  I now have only one CC, under a major player, "Capital One".  They have a true customer protection system, and I keep watch on this account closely.  They have notified me twice when something 'odd' has happened, not including the time my account was stolen - they made good on that.  They are a decent CC company.
One danger people face with CCs, is that by the time they receive the paper account balance notice by mail, it is already two weeks or more out of date.  This makes it easy to get into trouble.  I had that problem years ago, got into major CC debt.  I worked out of that, and went without a CC for a long while.  But the facts of modern life make at least a small CC necessary at times.  It is also a great 'convenience' IF one keeps a tight rein on it.  I have found keeping my lower credit limit to be no bad effect on my credit rating.  I kept checking it as I worked off the debt, and it steadily rose from the gutter.  Using this one card helped immensely.  I had zero problem when I bought my minivan, and had a good credit rating.  I get a credit score report via my CC company periodically and it remains good.
 
Nice write up Canine!

I was in the cash only world for years, armed only with cash and my debit card. I've been lucky to have never had a problem with it. However, a CC just makes things easier when reserving rooms, car rentals, and such. Especially about the hold system. Still makes me nervous with that feeling like I 'owe' someone until it's paid though. But I'm getting used to it.

I have the BoA cash back one, so far it's worked pretty good, made some money while not paying interest was nice. But then had to use it for a few months to live on while the RV sold, so it took some of that earnings, dangit. Still, I'm happy with it so far. A low limit Capital One that is also good so far. And a low limit Walfart one, you know.. just in case. They are everywhere, and figured if things got severely bad, I wouldn't starve quite as fast, lol. I intend to keep them separated while traveling.

As for PayPal... I hadn't used it in so long I didn't even remember my login. Pain in the rear! So, I just avoid. Now I'm glad, after hearing Lee's horror story.

Thanks for the great info!
 
There's a category of cards that functions like a credit card for purchases (Visa/MC), but requires pre-loading, like a gift card.  Can be done repeatedly, load it as needed.  Anyone know what that type of card is called?

Vagabound
 
I beleive prepaid cards have about the same legal protections as debt cards -- not much. Also they usually have non-use fees, so if you put money in and don't use it soon they take it out. :-( Single store gift cards are good until the store goes out of business, and you can sell them to places like cardcash.com. (You can also buy them there, sometimes with significant discount. When they had "extra 5% off" sales, I got grocery cards for over 6% off.)
 
Optimistic Paranoid said:

John, good info.  Put me on the right track to learn more.  Thanks.

A few good related links for anyone else interested:
* Consumer Affairs comparison list
NerdWallet’s Best Prepaid Debit Cards of 2016
* CardRates.com 2016 Best Prepaid and Debit Cards
* thesimpledollar.com - Best Prepaid Debit Cards of 2016

If anyone comes to any conclusions about those cards above, or has any personal experience with them, I'd be interested to know.  Thanks.

----------

The next thing I need to know relates to PayPal.  Despite its problems for sellers, I wonder how safe a place it is to park money for safekeeping, vs. a normal checking account.

Vagabound
 
Just be careful and read the fine print (and remember it!) on those Reloadable Prepaid Cards.

A friend loaded hers just before taking off on a 2 week vacation with the kids. Turns out there was a maximum load limit which was less than what she had put on the card AND a daily maximum spending limit that was so low she couldn't gas up her vehicle and pay for a campsite in the same day.

The CC company refused to refund her the excess she'd put on the card. She ended up borrowing from her ex mil to take the vacation. It took her forever to deal with the CC company and get her money back.

I used Paypal extensively when I ran my own craft business in the eastern US.. I would let the money sit in the paypal account and use it as needed to order shipments of material.

Aside from not being able to use a debit card with it, it operated exactly the same as any bank account would.
 
Almost There said:
... Turns out there was a maximum load limit which was less than what she had put on the card
...
The CC company refused to refund her the excess she'd put on the card. ... It took her forever to deal with the CC company and get her money back.
...

Aside from [Paypal] not being able to use a debit card with it, it operated exactly the same as any bank account would.

AT, good info and advice.  Thanks.  Makes me wonder if what seems like an obvious software bug (allowing more to be loaded than the maximum) was in fact deliberate. Preventing that problem from the card-side would have been the simplest of programming and on a checklist of basic functionality.

If you know or can easily find out, it would be nice to know the name of the prepaid card.

Vagabound
 
I use ONLY ash, PayPal and prepaid. :)
My ex wife ruined my credit, I only work for cash, and for privacy reasons, the prepaid cards are amazing.
I use the green dot, I can load it at any Wally, dollar gen, and many others. Also, it has an account and routing number so I am able to x-fer funds from PayPal to my card.
It has been a life saver as I have been without a sab of my own since 2011 ( no real address).
I am also able to x-fer funds to bitcoin.
The thing about paypal and prepaid cards is you need to know the game they play and play it as well.
This is an excellent and very interesting thread to me.
I'd love to have a bank account or major card hahaha
Be well friends
Peace
bLEEp
 
bLEEp said:
I use ONLY  ash, PayPal and prepaid. :)
...
The thing about paypal and prepaid cards is you need to know the game they play and play it as well.
...

Helpful.  Thanks.  Though I normally save the ash for when I'm grieving medieval style.  

(I know you meant "cash" ;-)

If you'd care to share more about how you use the card (how using the card is different from standard credit cards) and a bit about the game you mentioned, I'd be interested to know it, and others would probably benefit also.

Vagabound
 
Hehehehe
I was burning some midnight oil, the KB on my phablet seems to get smaller as the night/morning wears on. :)
I use MY card for traditional debit purchases, from gas to online bills, to ordering supplies for my crafting career.
As far as the "game" is concerned:
Each card will be different, some load at many locations, some are limited.
Whoever mentioned the fine print was spot on.
With my card, it acts like a true debit card, it has a name imprinted on it, has the "visa debit" imprinted on a gold card so it appears as if I am using a bank or credit card. (appearance can be important in some situations, as much as this long hair hates to admit it)
It is attached to a real address, has a link to a SS number, all of the security features you would be familiar with from other traditional cards.
You have access to live customer care both online and over the phone, sometimes it is nice to talk to someone about certain issues.
As long as you do not deposit more than 9,999 dollars at one time there is pretty much no reason to worry as far as IRS is concerned.
Most of the cards will allow a maximum of 10k to be carried at once.
If you load at least 1,000 per month there is no service charge on the card I carry.
There is a 4 dollar fee to add cash, seems like a minimal fee for a person like me.
There are MANY ATMs that can be used, however I rarely use one as my work is 90% cash at festivals and gatherings.
The paypal thing is what I really like. I can turn my paypal sales into spendable money very easily using the cards account and routing number, paypal treats it like a bank account.
Best for me is the stealth factor. I can not get into my issues at the moment but I will say it is important that my spending is kept private, and this is about as private as can be.
The card is secure, not attached to me in anyway, and functional.
If anyone would like more details please feel free to PM me I'm always willing to help someone get around "the matrix" as undetected as possible.
Peas :)
bLEEp
 
Vagabound said:
There's a category of cards that functions like a credit card for purchases (Visa/MC), but requires pre-loading, like a gift card.  Can be done repeatedly, load it as needed.  Anyone know what that type of card is called?

Vagabound

"Scam". Read my earlier posts, as this was the type card I was using. Maybe some are honest, the one I had were thieves. Buyer beware. Check online for reviews by customers before committing to them.
 
Make sure you don't preload any cards that are not behind a register and secured from tampering. Crooks are now taking the cards in displays and getting the pin number under the scratch off strip. They put them back with a new scratch off strip and lurk electronically for you to load the cards and scoop up the money. A new scam to me I just heard about.
 
Top